November 20, 2008 
 
End of the Road
Dellamorte reviews Star Wars THE CLONE WARS on Blu-ray
Dellamorte says it’s hard not to love Guillermo del Toro
HELLBOY II: The Golden Army Blu-ray review
SUNSET BOULEVARD The Centennial Collection DVD Review
Monika says the Centennial Collection of Sunset Boulevard is the sort of release one hopes for in an old film
A Miracle on Gower Street
Dellamorte reviews KUNG FU PANDA on Blu-ray
Actors are Misanthropic
Dellamorte reviews TROPIC THUNDER Director’s Cut on Blu-ray
Collider goes to PIXAR for the Home Video Release of WALL-E
A recap of what we did plus video from the Pixar campus!
WALL-E 3-Disc Special Edition DVD Review
Cal says that one of the year's best films is now one of the year's best DVDs
WALL-E Blu-ray Review
Dellamorte says Pixar has a very good batting average
I DREAM OF JEANNIE: The Complete Series DVD Review
Nico says he was too young to appreciate how sexy Barbara Eden was when he watched Jeannie as a kid
TROPIC THUNDER Unrated Director’s Cut DVD Review
What makes Tropic Thunder standout is not only its ruthless berating of its target, but also its attention to character detail
THE RON HOWARD SPOTLIGHT COLLECTION DVD Review
A Beautiful Mind, Cinderella Man, Apollo 13 and Backdraft
SABRINA Paramount Centennial Collection DVD Review
Audrey, Humphrey and Holden, beautifully restored. Need I say more?
THE BEST FILMS YOU’VE NEVER SEEN – James Napoli’s Rental of the Week
This week: LEMMING (2005)
KUNG FU PANDA and SECRETS OF THE FURIOUS FIVE DVD Reviews
Gil says although it may not be as strong as the best of the Pixar movies, Panda still holds its own as kickass animated film
 
DVD REVIEWS
MADAGASCAR Blu-ray Review
10/10/2008
Posted by
ColliderStaff

 
 
Review by Brett Weinstock

 

Pixar is known for making fabulous movies, there’s no doubt about that.  However, Madagascar was not one of their strongest titles, and they recently released a Blu-ray version of the film.  If you didn’t already know, the film is centered on four spoiled zoo animals enjoy the comforts and attention of many New Yorkers.  Marty, the zebra voiced by Chris Rock, decides he wants to leave the zoo and be free- he wants to live in the “wild.”  You see, each year on his birthday, Marty falls into a deep depression and longs for the thrill of wilderness.  On his tenth birthday, he learns of a devious plan by a quartet of penguins to escape the Central Park Zoo and pursue the freedom that has thus far evaded them.  Since all of this happens in the first ten or twelve minutes, the movie gets cooking fairly fast.  The other animals wake up to see Marty’s cage empty and they all sneak out to find him at the train station.

 

Once captured, the animals (voiced by Ben Stiller, David Schwimmer, and Jada Pinkett Smith) are put aboard a shipping boat and headed for another zoo.  Since these lovable animals just can’t stand the idea of captivity, they rock and roll their way off the boat and into the surrounding ocean.  A short while later, they end up shipwrecked on the beautiful island of Madagascar.  From here, we really get a true sense of the characters in the film, and they are all pretty unique. Once on the island, the animals meet with a group of lemurs, led by the “king” and his sidekick (voiced by Sacha Baron Cohen and Cedric the Entertainer).  The lemurs feel that these new animals are there to protect them from the evil creatures inhabiting the island and constantly attempting to feast on their young.  This sets up an interesting dynamic, because though the lemurs aren’t particularly fond of Alex (the lion) and his friends, they feel that they are necessary for their survival.

 

Even though the movie is a few years old, I am still not impressed with the overall attention to character detail.  It’s hard to believe that this is the same team that created and mastered the Shrek franchise.  Even though this film is animation, I still had trouble believing it for some reason.   The movie is set on a tropical island, but I never found myself getting completely lost in its beauty and environment.   The most important thing however is the dialogue itself which is also mostly unimpressive.  Don’t get me wrong, this is a movie for children- but almost every other Pixar film has some jokes that will appeal to adults.  The writing in this movie was just too cliché and cheesy for me- but maybe I am being too hard on DreamWorks.

 

Usually, a high-def version of a film comes with several bonus features not found on the standard version.  In Madagascar, this is unfortunately not the case- just about every special feature is recycled from the two year old DVD version.  Though they look nicer in 1080p, they are still old and don’t add anything new or fresh to the title.  The lone addition is a trivia pop-up that feels fun, yet tacked-on.   Overall, I was disappointed with the title because the standard DVD two years ago felt packed with special features, while this fell majorly short.

 

Overall, if you love this movie and feel that you must own it on high-def, check this out.  I can’t whole heartedly recommend it because I don’t feel the need to repurchase a DVD you have bought two years ago.   Though the film is fun, there is no need to buy it again, and this Blu-ray version should honestly, though sadly be overlooked.

 

Film Rating: B-

Special Features: C (nothing new)

 

         



 
More Collider DVD Stories >>>
Collider Watches 15 Minutes of STAR TREK

End of the Road

5 Clips from Next Week’s HEROES – The Eclipse Part 1

TWILIGHT has joined the list of Top Ten Advance Ticket-Sellers on Fandango

What Was the 1991 version of BEAUTY AND THE BEAST missing?

Disney Lives Large with IMAX 3-D

2009 Sundance Opens with World Premiere of Adam Elliot’s MARY AND MAX

Gore Verbinski Finds The Perfect HOST

THE SOLOIST Shuffle

Danny Boyle Exclusive Video Interview SLUMDOG MILLIONAIRE

BOLT – 4 Movie Clips, a Featurette, the Trailer and a Music Video

CAPTAIN AMERICA Requires More Bland