October 13, 2008 
 
5 Movie Clips from THE SECRET LIFE OF BEES
Starring Queen Latifah, Dakota Fanning, Jennifer Hudson, Alicia Keys, Tristan Wilds and Paul Bettany
Ridley Scott goes to WAR
Joe Haldeman's sci-fi classic is headed to the big screen in some very good hands.
Exclusive Clip from SEX DRIVE
This clip will show you why everyone is raving about this comedy!
Collider Exclusive – Mark Wahlberg is Not in SMOKE JUMPERS!
Contrary to all the online rumors, Mark says it’s Jason Patrick that’ll work with Vinnie Chase and Edward Norton
First Photos of Jude Law as Dr. Watson in SHERLOCK HOLMES
An honorary member of the Stache Club
Ridley Scott Gets Beat By A CHIHUAHUA
Nicole writes about the weekend box office
7 Movie Clips and the Trailer from PRIDE AND GLORY
Starring Edward Norton, Colin Farrell, Jon Voight and Noah Emmerich
7 Movie Clips from MAX PAYNE
Starring Mark Wahlberg, Mila Kunis, Olga Kurylenko, Chris ‘Ludacris’ Bridges and Beau Bridges
Jennifer Carpenter Exclusive Video Interview – QUARANTINE
We talk about the unusual ways they made Quarantine and her work on Dexter
Jay Hernandez and Columbus Short Exclusive Video Interview – QUARANTINE
And Collider asks if playing a firefighter and police officer in Quarantine will help them land a role in Smoke Jumpers
SHERLOCK HOLMES Like You've Never Seen Before!
Because this is the first image!
Visitors V-Turn
Warner Bros. goes for a Television V-make
The Funny Kind of Cancer
Seth Rogen has CANCER and he's bringing it to a theater near you
Final TWILIGHT Trailer Goes Online
If you are a TWILIGHT fan, this was also your night…
QUARANTINE Movie Review
Brian reviews the American remake of the 2007 Spanish horror film titled REC
Who Will Helm del Toro's HATER?
How about the guy who helmed del Toro's THE ORPHANAGE
 
ARCHIVE - ENTERTAINMENT REVIEWS
Movie Review – A MIGHTY HEART
6/21/2007
Posted by
Collider

Reviewed by Brian Orndorf

 

In many ways, "Mighty Heart" is a natural extension of last year's masterpiece, "United 93." Both films bravely dramatize real-world terror in increasingly artistic ways that lack exploitation, emphasizing the emotional reality and fear when faced with acts of terrorism. However, "Heart" comes from filmmaker Michael Winterbottom, a director who isn't known for his acute expression of feelings.

         

On assignment soon after 9/11 in Karachi, Pakistan, journalist Daniel Pearl (Dan Futterman, at his most frustratingly distanced) was chasing the trail of terrorist Richard Reid when he was kidnapped. At home, his wife Mariane (Angelina Jolie), at five month's pregnant, became a driving force to bring her husband home. Through arrests, interrogation, betrayals, and false leads, the case to find Pearl lasted a month before it was learned that the beloved reported, husband, and father-to-be was beheaded by Pakistan terrorists. 

 

"Heart" approaches the story of Pearl through chilly exhibition. Winterbottom appreciates how the hunt for Pearl was carried out instead of lamenting the tragedy that met the world at the end of speculation. In many ways, this is how "Heart" can breathe and inch toward the horror without losing its step.

         

"Heart" isn't a history lesson, but more a procedural drama watching government forces from several countries team up to find Pearl. It's antiseptic filmmaking, relying on the facts and rumors of the tense time to erect a tale of semi-suspense and clarification. Clouded in rightful displays of anger and mourning, it's interesting to see Pearl's last steps played out again; the director paints a disturbing portrait of terrorist baiting and manipulation that no one could've foreseen. 

         

Like "United 93," "Heart" isn't ghoulish or a piece of activism – a concept that Winterbottom has struggled with in recent years as his vision was slowly drained by his arrogance. This is filmmaker who not long ago made striking portraits of loneliness ("Wonderland") and politics (Welcome to Sarajevo"), but soon lost his patience with the film world and was flushed into an oeuvre of tedious experimentation. "Heart" allows Winterbottom to locate a focal point again, concentrating his gifts on delicately creating a story that has little need for political rhetoric or excessive melodrama.

         

In fact, the emotion that manages to tiptoe into the film is massaged powerfully by the filmmaker, choosing carefully the moments of Mariane's despair and ultimately her cathartic wail that greets the news of Daniel's beheading. Jolie and Winterbottom seem to have this heavily considered game plan for reveal, and "Heart" is all the more striking because of it. Jolie is allowed to retain Mariane's remarkable poise in the face of loss, and the director doesn't have to succumb to a syrupy, mournful tone the rest of the film hasn't been prepped for.

         

"Mighty Heart" is not easy cinema to absorb, but this film is not interested in distress. The story told here is one of lives shattered and hope restored, vividly encapsulating sacrifice and loss in a world gone mad.

 

----  B plus



 
More Collider Entertainment Stories >>>
RUN FATBOY RUN DVD Review

5 Movie Clips from THE SECRET LIFE OF BEES

10 YARDS (Fantasy Football) DVD Review

PSYCHO Universal Legacy Series DVD Review

HALLOWEEN Three-Disc Unrated Collector's Edition DVD Review

Ridley Scott goes to WAR

Exclusive Clip from SEX DRIVE

Collider Exclusive – Mark Wahlberg is Not in SMOKE JUMPERS!

INDIANA JONES AND THE KINGDOM OF THE CRYSTAL SKULL DVD Review

First Photos of Jude Law as Dr. Watson in SHERLOCK HOLMES

Ridley Scott Gets Beat By A CHIHUAHUA

7 Movie Clips and the Trailer from PRIDE AND GLORY