RSS
 
  July 04, 2009 
 
Collider’s RSS Feed – VERY IMPORTANT
A new Collider is launching...
Review: TERMINATOR SALVATION
Matt can't find the humanity in this war against the machines
You'll Get Your First Look at James Cameron's AVATAR in Front of TRANSFORMERS: REVENGE OF THE FALLEN
But I have my doubts...
Clips from Accidentally on Purpose, NCIS LA, The Good Wife, and Three Rivers
Take an early look at CBS’ fall shows
CBS Announces 2009-2010 Primetime Schedule
The network add four series and moves The Mentalist to Thursdays
The first reviews of Quentin Tarantino's INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS
Apparently it's 'too talky'; have these critics seen a Tarantino movie before?
Three Clips from INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS - UPDATED with a 4th Clip
Jew Rats, Interrogating Nazis, and Chatting with a Wounded Diane Kruger
Sam Worthington Interview TERMINATOR SALVATION
He talks about everything – from making Terminator to James Cameron’s Avatar
Christian Bale Interview TERMINATOR SALVATION
He talks about making Terminator, Public Enemies, and how he’s training for his next film
Steven Soderbergh Interview – THE GIRLFRIEND EXPERIENCE
He talks about making Girlfriend Experience and a little bit on Moneyball
Dan Aykroyd Says GHOSTBUSTERS 3 Could Start Filming This Winter
Starting up a 'new generation' of ghostbusters
New Trailer: 9
An awesome-looking animated film that isn't from Pixar
First Look At ABC's FLASH FORWARD and V
Two of the network's upcoming sci-fi drama series
NBC Announces 2009-2010 Primetime Schedule
And Chuck is back…but not until February
ABC UNVEILS 2009-10 PRIMETIME SCHEDULE
V is back
TWILIGHT NEW MOON Teaser Movie Poster
Bella, Edward and Jacob…
 
ENTERTAINMENT REVIEWS
AUSTRALIA Movie Reviews
11/24/2008
Posted by
Matt
     

 

 

Update: Brian has also reviewed Australia and his review is below Matt’s. Unlike a lot of movies where everyone has the same opinion, Matt and Brian had completely different reaction’s to Baz Luhrmann’s new film….the negative review is first….

 
 
Written by Matt Goldberg

 

Baz Lurhmann's first film in almost a decade is wrapped in the veneer of an epic.  It's old Hollywood through and through with touches of "Gone with the Wind", "Giant", "From Here to Eternity", and "Red River" along with a heavy helping of "The Wizard of Oz".  And yet this mixture of influences from Hollywood's first Golden Age all feels distinctly hollow because Luhrmann can't combine it into something original nor does he use it as a mean of telling an original story. 

 

Constantly weaving around and away from its originality, "Australia" is told through the eyes of a half-white, half-aboriginal boy named Nullah (Brandon Walters).  His narration is the film's first and perhaps largest error.  The idea to have a sweeping epic told through the eyes of a child isn't necessarily a bad idea, but when told through a totally pure child who wears his poor English and ignorance (or innocence if you prefer) like a badge of honor, I feel like I'm supposed to be reading a book a la "Their Eyes Were Watching God" rather than being engaged by an active storyteller.

 

Nullah's story tells of Lady Sarah Ashley (Nicole Kidman, an Aussie playing a Brit who goes to Australia) and her love affair with Drover (Hugh Jackman) against the backdrop of sinister cattle rustlers attempting to swindle Ashley out of her land and her profits.  When this storyline is resolved at only ninety minutes, the film gets another fresh hour out of the bombing of Darwin by the Japanese in 1941.  But the happiness of all the good characters is threatened by the sinister and cartoony Neil Fletcher (David Wenham) whose sole purpose in life is to be an evil fuck.  I didn't know whether he was going to try and bankrupt Lady Ashley or tie her to some railroad tracks.  If you think that latter scenario is out the realm of possibility, you should know that at one point, Fletcher kills a guy by knocking him into a pit of crocodiles.

 

With only imitations of epic Hollywood characters instead of the actual shading those original characters possessed, the performances are weak all around.  Walters' job is to be wide-eyed and adorable.  Kidman is atrocious as she bounces from madcap comedy to Scarlett O'Hara resilience with all the subtlety of a sledgehammer.  Jackman just seems bored by the whole enterprise and I can't say I blame him.  Then again, I don't know how much I can blame the actors when they have so little to work with.  Just because you're supposed to be in the vein of Rhett Butler, doesn't mean you get his character arc.

 

While I don't necessarily mind the throwback, I do mind that it's being used as a distraction rather than a showpiece.  The original story and the one that's worth telling is Nullah's.  His life as a bi-racial child in 1941 Australia set against the pre-modern mysticism of the aboriginal peoples crashing against the modern world's government-sanctioned racism and world war—this is the story worth telling.  But when you're sitting next to the epic love story of Sarah and Drover, mysticism looks silly.  When your leads are two beautiful looking white people who are cut from a 1940s Hollywood epic, then your aboriginal characters are not people with their own histories and destinies, but noble savages that can be sacrificed so whitey gets a happy ending.  It's like Luhrmann is selling out one culture so that he can treat us to one we already know.

 

Case and point: Nullah and Ashley develop a close mother-son relationship and the song they sing to each other is "Somewhere Over the Rainbow".  It's a song we all know and love but the problem is we already know and already love it. I couldn't help but wonder, "What's Nullah's song?  Why doesn't Nullah teach a song to Sarah rather than having to assimilate into her culture?"  When they're about to be separated, Nullah says to Sarah, "I'll sing you to me," but it's not his song.  The life of the aboriginal people has to work within the framework Luhrmann's constructed from Golden Age cinema. 

 

It's a sad irony that a film called "Australia" seems to have very little to do with that country and almost everything to do with how we imagined ours.  It's a film lost in its own aesthetic and it's an aesthetic which spills over into the story and embraces the nostalgic while washing away the elements that could make the film feel fresh and original.  "Australia" could have taught us all a new tune but instead it's just playing the same old song.

 

Rating ----- D plus

 

 

AUSTRALIA Movie Review by Brian Orndorf

           

"Australia" is not a motion picture odyssey for curmudgeons or cynics. Director Baz Luhrmann is stretching for classic movie poses within a film of marathon sweep and locale, and he achieves his lofty goals with this exhaustively enchanting romantic adventure, making the obscene wait between movies (seven years!) seem all the more easy to comprehend. Luhrmann isn't desperate to rewrite the rules of cinematic spectacle with "Australia," he only wants to play in the sandbox of yesteryear's lavish big screen achievements, while drizzling on his own imaginative flourishes.

 

Arriving from England pre-WWII, Sarah Ashley (Nicole Kidman) has come to sort out the troubles plaguing her sprawling Northern Australian cattle ranch, Faraway Downs. Finding her husband dead, corrupt caretakers, and an Aboriginal family with nowhere to turn to, Sarah seizes control of the land, much to the dismay of King Carney (Bryan Brown), a rival cattle baron with eyes on purchasing Faraway Downs. Removing the insidious Fletcher (David Wenham) from the property, Sarah is left without help. Enter Drover (Hugh Jackman), a weathered man of the outback who comes to Sarah's aid, whipping the ranch hands into shape, and finding a place for Nullah (Brandon Walters), a "half-caste" Aboriginal boy trying to avoid governmental detainment during the harsh "Stolen Generations" years. Driving the cattle across the ruthless landscape, romance quickly blossoms between Drover and Sarah, soon threatened by the dawn of WWII and Fletcher's unstoppable efforts to exact revenge.

 

While "Australia" is a return to more patient blockbuster filmmaking, it doesn't exactly mean Luhrmann has rid himself of his cheek-slapping sense of humor. Much like his 1996 blast of style "Romeo Juliet," "Australia" opens with a good 20 minutes of severe compositional behavior to unsettle the audience before they're eventually comforted. Whirring around from location to location to set up the story and introduce the audience to a plethora of characters and motivations, Luhrmann is shot out of a cannon, intriguingly blurring expectations as "Australia" starts to settle down. This brief glimpse of Luhrmann's more impish behavior is a nice callback to past triumphs, while also thrusting the audience into a strange world of the titular landscape, positioning the viewer in the foreigner role, much like Sarah, taking in the natural majesty of Faraway Downs and the brutal survival instincts required from its residents with eyes wide open.

 

Once Sarah assumes her responsibility and Drover asserts his cattle knowledge, beginning an understaffed drive across treacherous terrain, "Australia" begins to take customary shape, angling toward the "Gone with the Wind" and "Lawrence of Arabia" style scope that seems to tickle Luhrmann's fancy the most. A tale of grizzled men, delicate but steely women, and the naturalistic hazards that intimidate relentlessly, the film won't snatch any awards for originality, but the conviction of the filmmaking is second to none. Luhrmann takes "Australia" to dazzling heights of romantic sincerity and nerve-racking adventure, toying with screen archetypes without a hint of irony; the filmmaker appears fully invested in creating a genuine motion picture event of good vs. evil. Luhrmann has always held a soft spot for love stories, but here he's shooting for bigness to backdrop emotional simplicity. And I'll be damned, it works.

 

"Australia" may not be the most understated of movies, but lending it a distinctive personality is the country itself, and how determined Luhrmann is to keep international flavors out of the mix. This is an Aussie tale all the way to the bone, using pivotal moments of wartime ruin and racial hostility to help fatten the story beyond Drover and Sarah's domesticated affair. In fact, the film belongs to Nullah, who represents the Aboriginal injustice and divine mysticism of the screenplay, with Luhrmann using the boy to embody issues of unfettered bigotry and cultural divide (see "Rabbit-Proof Fence" for another take on this gut-churning moment in Aussie history). Beyond the fact that Walters gives one of those all-too-rare performances of pure youthful instinct and curiosity the film mines exquisitely, the character comes to be a screen presence the film cannot survive without, forming a triangle of charisma and emotional intensity with Drover and Sarah that the director preserves beautifully over the film's 160-minute-long running time.

 

Indeed, "Australia" is a lengthy movie, but not one to mope around. Watching the story embark on a blazing cattle drive, portion out Fletcher's boiling rage, or smoothly bring together Drover and Sarah as they bond in the outback maintains a strict pace to the movie. There's a swarm of fluid emotions and action sequences to gorge on here, and with both Jackman and Kidman in top form in the lead roles (the actors are energetic and unfathomably alluring), "Australia" is a painless film to immerse oneself in, especially with all the gorgeous locales and vivid costuming to keep the eye occupied. 

 

A western of Aussie proportions for the first two acts (blessed with cast of local talents, including the legendary David Gulpilil as Nullah's watchful grandfather), the narrative slips into war mode in the final section, when WWII washes up on Australian shores (depicted here with the bombing of Darwin) and divides our heroes. Here, Luhrmann opens his widescreen framing to the limits of multiplex dimension, staging bombing raids and populace chaos with the proper mix of hysteria and teary melodrama. The cast sells the stuffing out of anything the script gives them, creating more of a poignant journey for the final act than a violent one. The conclusion also pays off a running theme of the movie: the calming magic of "The Wizard of Oz." With "Over the Rainbow" employed by Sarah to console and bewitch Nullah's fascination with music, Luhrmann tethers himself to the song and reapplies it everywhere, as a sort of emotional touchstone and communal cinematic tribute. It's a lovely touch.

 

Let me be clear: "Australia" is not for the average misanthrope, and those less inclined to swallow Luhrmann's slippery theatricality will find themselves with bleeding eyes, clawing at the walls to exit the theater. For the more inclined, "Australia" is a dramatically fertile, immersive gem: an epic with true epic intentions and execution, reinvesting in patient storytelling and widescreen magnetism.

 
---  A minus




 
     
More Collider Entertainment Stories >>>
Collider’s RSS Feed – VERY IMPORTANT

Review: TERMINATOR SALVATION

You'll Get Your First Look at James Cameron's AVATAR in Front of TRANSFORMERS: REVENGE OF THE FALLEN

Clips from Accidentally on Purpose, NCIS LA, The Good Wife, and Three Rivers

CBS Announces 2009-2010 Primetime Schedule

The first reviews of Quentin Tarantino's INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS

Three Clips from INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS - UPDATED with a 4th Clip

Sam Worthington Interview TERMINATOR SALVATION

Christian Bale Interview TERMINATOR SALVATION

Steven Soderbergh Interview – THE GIRLFRIEND EXPERIENCE

Dan Aykroyd Says GHOSTBUSTERS 3 Could Start Filming This Winter

X-MEN ORIGINS: WOLVERINE Uncaged Edition Xbox 360 Review